The Numbers Don't Lie!
As we move further into fall, the Garden City real estate market continues to tell an interesting story. October brought more listings, steady buyer activity, and higher average sale prices compared to this time last year.
Welcome back to my Chart Room, where I take a closer look at what's really happening in our local market. By comparing current activity with previous months and years, my goal is to cut through the noise and provide buyers and sellers with a clearer picture of the Garden City real estate market.
October brought 15 new listings, a 25% increase over October 2025. For buyers who have been navigating limited inventory, this is encouraging news. More homes on the market mean more choices and opportunities.
Meanwhile, 13 homes went under contract, matching last October's activity and suggesting that buyer demand remains steady.
One of the more interesting developments was in closed sales. While the number of homes sold declined from 25 last October to 16 this year, the average sale price increased 7.1% to approximately $1.758 million.
It's a good reminder that fewer sales don't necessarily mean a weaker market. The types of homes selling, their locations, and their price ranges all influence the monthly averages.
With a median of just 16.5 days on market, October's closed sales also demonstrate that many homes are continuing to attract buyers relatively quickly.
I also wanted to take a closer look at how our market changed in just one month, which is why I'm sharing a second At a Glance graphic comparing September and October 2026.
The differences are worth noting!
New listings increased from 12 to 15, homes going under contract jumped from 8 to 13, and closed sales rose from 7 to 16. The average sale price also climbed from approximately $1.56 million in September to $1.758 million in October.
That's quite a bit of movement in just 30 days!
Of course, monthly numbers can fluctuate, especially in a community like Garden City, where a relatively small number of sales can influence the averages. But looking at these trends together helps us better understand the direction of our local market.
If there's one thing I continue to emphasize through my Chart Room, it's that real estate is hyperlocal.
What we hear about the national housing market doesn't always reflect what's happening right here in Garden City.
For buyers, increased inventory may present new opportunities, but desirable, well-priced homes can still move quickly. For sellers, strong sale prices are encouraging, but thoughtful pricing, preparation, and marketing remain essential.
As we approach the end of 2026, I'll be watching how inventory, buyer demand, and sale prices evolve through the holiday season.
Whether you're considering buying or selling, or simply curious about your home's value, I'm always happy to share my knowledge and help you understand what these numbers mean for you.
The numbers don't lie, and local knowledge makes all the difference!
Cheryl Adams McAuliffe
Howard Hanna Coach Realtors
Real Data. Local Insight. A Clearer View of What's Next.

All information pulled from the Multiple Listing System (MLS). Market data reflects homes within the Garden City School District.