The Garden City real estate market remained highly competitive throughout May 2026, with buyer demand continuing to outpace available inventory. While the number of new listings declined compared to the previous month, well-priced homes continued to attract strong interest and move into contract quickly.
During May, 17 new homes came to market within the Garden City School District, down from April. At the same time, 22 properties went under contract, demonstrating that buyers remain active despite limited inventory. This imbalance between supply and demand continues to create favorable conditions for sellers. Overall, there was one fewer active listing than the previous month, reflecting the ongoing shortage of available homes.
A total of 14 homes closed during the month, an increase over April. The average sale price was approximately $1.45 million, while the average days on market increased to 36 days. Although homes are taking slightly longer to sell than earlier this spring, the market remains healthy, with buyers continuing to compete for desirable properties in many price ranges. These local trends generally align with broader Garden City housing data showing prices remaining resilient despite limited inventory.
For both buyers and sellers, today's market rewards preparation. Sellers who price strategically and present their homes well continue to benefit from strong demand, while buyers who are financially prepared and ready to act quickly are giving themselves the best opportunity to secure a home in this competitive market.
If you're thinking about buying or selling in Garden City, I'd be happy to discuss what these market trends mean for your specific situation and provide a personalized analysis of your home's value or your buying strategy.
Cheryl Adams McAuliffe
Howard Hanna Coach Realtors
Serving Garden City, NY and the surrounding communities since 2002

|
|
If the email address was found in our system, your password has been sent. Please check your inbox.
Back to Login
We respect your concerns about privacy and value the relationship that we have with you.
Like many sites, we use cookies on our website to collect information to help improve your browsing experience. The cookies that we use allow our website to work and help us to understand what information is most useful to visitors.
For the best website browsing experience, please enable cookies. Go here for instructions on how to enable cookies on your browser.